Welcome to Home Theater Focus Blogs Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

  • “Bubble” released to theaters. And DVD and Pay TV

    It’s an historic event, the release of a movie that involves a major Hollywood name like Steven Soderbergh.  His latest film Bubble is being released to three different formats all at the same time.  It might have happened with some little known indie flick already but never one that went into nationwide release like Bubble.  Even though it is an art house film, probably wouldn’t have made any waves were it not for the unique approach to its release. 

     

    Soderbergh is an Oscar winning directory who is no stranger to innovation.  His film credits include Traffic, Erin Brockovich and Sex, Lies and Videotape.  He shoots his movies with an HD digital camera and has entered into an agreement to make six films with an independent studio called 2929. 

     

    The big story here is that this release is probably being scrutinized deeply by Hollywood.  It could be the way that Hollywood films do business in the future whether they like it or not.  The major studios felt threatened by TV way back in the 50’s, but not until the last few years has a variation of those fears finally come to pass.  People still want movies but statistics show they want to see them on their own terms.  DVD releases of major films now make more money than the film’s box office.  According to Hollywood Reporter in 2004 theaters generated $9.5 billion.  But DVD / VHS raked in about $26 billion.

     

    According to Roger Ebert:

     

    “Everything about the film – its casting, its filming, its release – is daring and innovative.” 

     

    The film is about ordinary people who work in a doll factory in Ohio, but there is also a murder to make all that talking and doll making interesting.  Ebert gives it a four out of four star rating.

  • Get Ready for MooDiPod

    Mood sensing gimmicks are nothing new, they date back to the ancient Phoenicians.  Disney just patented a media player that is supposed to playback music based on your mood.  Mood sensing is done via a strap around your wrist that picks up your heart rate, temp, perspiration and translates it into a musical selection.  An algorithm is applied to the songs you accept and reject based on your mood, eventually a profile is built on you as the device learns what you like per your mood.  The language of the patent leaves it open to be connected to the internet and possibly access a third party library of songs and/or videos. 

     

    Is it just me being paranoid or is this creepy stuff?  If the device has access to the internet how valuable will your profile be to advertisers and maybe even the FBI, CIA, DOD, CTU and whoever else wants to tap your phones?   

     

    Yes, I’m indulging further idle speculation but it’s likely if Disney wants to put some real muscle behind this release they should use Apple’s iPod brand.  Steve Jobs has done business with Disney before.  Does anyone feel comfortable with Disney or Apple trying to get inside your head? 

     

    ATTENTION DISNEY!

    They already have mood playback methods.  They’re called playlists. 

     

    Here’s an idea.  How about a Disney/Apple chip you can have installed into your head that alters your mood so they can just decide what music to playback for you?  Then you can feed you a steady diet of American Idol winners and Diet Coke jingles and you can feel great about it.

  • More Digital Entertainment Business Chaos

    This is an interesting news article on Audioholics about the state of the entertainment industry, it illustrates the push / pull between media, content providers, hardware and operating systems.  All of these conditions are vying for influence, power and most of all their piece of the pie in this new world of digital entertainment. 

     

    It’s a fascinating story; each character has a unique angle.  The upstart Apple smashing down barriers in the media distribution arena with iTunes and now trying to do for television shows what it’s already done for music.  Gates and the Microsoft Empire tries to second guess the forthcoming landscape and make Windows Media Center and Vista all things to all people.  Can Win MC smash the PVR market and dominate digital entertainment like they’ve dominated the ‘puter?  Then of course there is Sony, the empire that is both on the hardware and entertainment sides of the fence.  It’s big business thrills, chills and spills all around.  The next few years will make for fascinating viewing in high definition.

     

    There is one other player, one newt running around the forest of dinosaurs that I’m hoping for.  It’s the artists themselves.  Artists like actors, directors and even producers being part of the media they know where their bread is buttered.  It's unlikley they'll stand against the big studio behemoth and in favor of new digital entertainment distribution paradigms.

     

    However. 

     

    "Bubble" is due to be released late this month and it’ll be the first film released simultaneously to theaters, digital cable and DVD.  Bubble is a small budget piece set in Ohio that is supposedly a good quality work that crosses genres.  It's shot completely on digital HD cameras with a non-professional cast. 

     

    What sets Bubble apart from any story of an indie production house trying something new is the director of Bubble is Award winning director Steven Soderbergh, the first director to run against himself for best director Oscars when Traffic and Erin Brockovich were nominated.

     

    Kudos to Soderbergh for having what it takes to show the world how it’s to be done in the digital entertainment era.

     

    About the image:  No, Aeon Flux has nothing to do with this story but Charlize Theron sure is pretty, eh?

  • What sucks about HDTV: Downrez Nazis, AACS

    The AACS or Advanced Access Content System is the consortium behind HD DVD and Blu-Ray's content protection.  Companies making hardware to playback these formats must play ball.  Last week the AACS came to an agreement about downrezzing, a longtime bogeyman of videophiles.

    Basically downrezzing is the act of downgrading (down-sampling) video signals from an HD playback device's analogue output.  Analogue or component video outputs on your new HD DVD or Blu-Ray players had been the focus of downrezzing rumors because content cannot be regulated through it.  Pirates can theoretically make unlimited copies from an analogue source so HDCP (High Definition Content Protection) was created to protect movie studios properties.  Your non-HDCP compliant video connections (IE component) are liable to be downrezzed on HD movie discs.  So, instead of getting full blown  1920 x 1080 resolution (up to full 1080P) from them you'll only get 960 x 540. 

    The feature (explained at VideoBusiness.com) on the new movie discs is called ICT, (Image Constraint Token) an embedded digital flag that can be turned on or off at the studios discretion.  Studios choosing to downrez their video release to an HD disc will be required to warn consumers on the packaging that this copy will be down-sampled from an analogue source.

    So far no studio has stated how they'll respond to the ICT option but there are rumors.  Warner is likely to enforce downgrading video quality on its releases because it had been the strongest proponent of the measure.  Its likely 20th Century Fox and Sony will tend not to use the ICT because they have argued against such measures in the past.

    It's just another example of legal constipation of technologies progress.  It's an inherently flawed philosophy that may one day be the downfall of mankind.

  • Cisco Systems jumping into the consumer electronics game

    Cisco Systems looks to expand into consumer electronics with items from phones, radios to home theater equipment.  Cisco made its mark with routers aimed at enterprise traffic volumes and have been a mainstay of the new internet economy.  The router company expanded into consumer markets with smaller routers for the home and other communications devices.

     

    In an interview this week Charles Giancarlo of Cisco's Chief Development Office told Financial Times : 

     

    Consumer electronics companies have been able to compete on a standalone device, but the dynamics of the market are changing…The Internet and new networking requirements are enough of a disruptor for us to enter a new market.” 

     

    I’m curious to see what they make for the HT market.  More wi-fi aware internet connected set top boxes are always welcome.  I just wonder what kind of sound quality they’ll put behind a DVD/CD ripping digital playback device.  Maybe it’s my own foolish prejudice but I’d trust the likes of Cambridge Audio or NAD with such a device before Cisco.  But who knows, maybe they’ll rock the house.  No word so far on any specific devices.

  • Hanspree Artisitic LCD TVs

    When I saw this little number on Gizmodo I though; “cool!”.  The Batman LCD TV is from a company called Hanspree who makes LCD displays built with style.  After looking at the company’s website I was completely enamored.  If I were of a mind to get a TV for my son’s room (Bruce Wayne) this would be it.  However, being an old school tyrant of a father I’m not inclined to make passive entertainment more accessible for a kid who should be playing outside in the dirt like we used to in the old days.  One giant LCD TV in the house is plenty.  I’d be proud to see him put up a new Hanspree monitor in his room if he saved up enough money he’d earned to buy it.

     

    Not all the Hanspree designs are for kids.  You really have to check out their website and see the styles they’re using to decorating an LCD panel.  It’s a unique, groundbreaking use of LCD technology, an idea that was definitely in mail the moment small LCD panels fell below a certain price.  The TVs themself are in the 15” range and have a variety of styles from sports to fantasy to some of the more sophisticated elegant styles to make TVs look like throwbacks to a past (or future) era.  Examining them through the company’s website is a pleasure.  Their website has images and even 360’ animations of each product.  Their lines of LCD TVs are divided neatly into categories making for simple navigation.  Other electronics companies could learn volumes on how to design a website from Hanspree.

  • OpenPeak SimpleRemote

    Electronics company employs the clever word - joining technique to create new brand based words for ModerNeNglish.

    OpenPeak is a small company that makes remote control devices specifically designed (so they say) to accomplish complex tasks as simple as possible to the user.  Universal Remote controls for Home Theater systems have certainly come of age.  You can get one button control of complete mood settings for your house that include lights and exact song selections.  OpenPeak has created the next step in household electronics integration with the remote control this is possibly the most advanced universal remote yet.  The SimpleRemote brings the home theater system, PC, internet and VoIP together.  Using the SimpleRemote you can access internet content like RSS news feeds, MP3 media library, right along side your DVD player and home theater receiver’s volume control.  It also integrates with VoIP (internet phone line) and will ring with an incoming call and will automatically pause the music/movie but only if you decide to take the call.  The device is wi-fi aware and has a 2.2” display for easy navigation and personal settings.

    I haven’t had a chance to play with this remote but it sure doesn’t sound very simple.  OpenPeak is proud of their integration with the internet and its interview setup.  It’s not the first device to conduct its initial setup through an interview with the user asking questions about other equipment it’ll be attached to.  Access to the Wi-Fi internet access (using your wireless router of course) is a great way for instant access to the correct drivers or codes to run your equipment.  Overall it looks like a great system.  I’m leery of branding the concept of simplicity into a universal remote.  I wish just once they’d brand a universal remote or similar device a little more honestly and up front.  Perhaps they next remote could be called “The Confounder”.  Or just have a warning label that says right on it:  Not recommended for persons over 35 years of age.

  • HD DVD / Blu-Ray and the truth about Managed Copy

     

    Microsoft announced an HD DVD external drive for Xbox 360 at CESI can just short of guarantee that by the time Microsoft gets around to releasing the external HD DVD drive for the Xbox 360 we’ll have forgotten all about it.  Xbox’s HD DVD won’t do well on the market.  Why?  When was the last time an external media reader sold like cigarettes at an AA meeting?  Remember the Sega CD drive?  But the real reason is simple.  Windows Vista Managed Copy.  There has been an ongoing brew-ha-ha over MC (Managed Copy) and AASC since the feature was announced.

     

    AACS stands for Advanced Access Content System.  It’s a system of Digital Rights Management or DRM. Nothing gets the computer nerd nation’s panty-hose more twisted up than the very idea of DRM.  The punk rock attitude is to hate anything that has to do with interfering with the free flow of data, hence lots of bitching already about AACS and MC.  Free information would seem a noble cause.  But railing against MC or AACS is misplaced anger.  DRM is here for good so get used to it kids.  Since we’re going to have DRM it’s far better to see a standard DRM in place that all studios use rather than see every company build their own.  Remember Sony’s RootKit? 

     

    Letting a digital entertainment provider build its own DRM is like hiring a coyote to guard the hen house.

     

    Managed Copy is going to be a feature in both HD DVD and Blu-Ray.  Blu-Ray will leave it up to the studio releasing the disc to decide what kind of DRM protection they want on their DVD and they can choose to use AACS and/or MC or not.  Not using it will only mean you cannot legally copy any content from the Blu-Ray disc and it’ll have some form of DRM attached to it.  If Paramount decides to use MC on the Blu-Ray version of Star Trek IV you’ll be able to make a perfect copy using the upcoming Windows Vista operating system easy as pie, just drag it onto any networked device approved for use with AACS, this will include Windows Media Player.  This should also include the Xbox 360.  A dedicated HD DVD drive isn’t going to be necessary for 75% of you because HD DVD (or Blu-Ray) drives for your PC will be cheaper and offer more benefits.

     

    HD DVD’s Managed Copy is mandatory.  Studios releasing an HD DVD disc must allow their content to be copied using this MC (and Windows Vista).  The wrinkle here is that neither Microsoft nor Toshiba (creator of the HD DVD format) can control whether or not the studio charges extra for MC or how many times AACS (the tubes and wires behind MC) will allow you to copy it to your local network.

     

    This is a potential cat turd squished under your mattress.  How will studios bill you for your additional copies?  Will we see MC in bullet points on the back of retail discs as a “special feature” pumping up the price?  Will we see special edition versions of discs released that cost more because they include MC? 

     

    • This feature has been authorized for Managed Copy and can be copied to any AACS device.

    My guess is the answer is yes.  But my opinion is “more power to ‘em”.  This whole MC controversy is all about apples vs oranges and both are a tasty treat.  Compare MC with what you’re dealing with now.  Everything is protected with DRM, you cannot currently copy any DVD to your hard-drive all methods of cracking and hacking notwithstanding.  You’ll always have the option to crack AACS in a matter of months after the first HD DVD or Blu-Ray disc hits the market, not that I recommend it of course.

  • Samsung to release first Blu-Ray player. Say hello to BD-P1000

    Samsung announced an April ’06 release for the first retail Blu-Ray player.  The BD-P1000 was unveiled at CES and will retail for $1000.  It’ll play BD discs at 720P or 1080i through its HDMI interface.  

     

    Also at CES ’06 Toshiba unveiled its early starter.  A March ’06 release is scheduled for Toshiba’s first HD DVD player.  

     

    Neither the Samsung nor Toshiba units will be able to handle the 1080P specification.  Pioneer will come to the rescue late in ’06 with a 1080P capable Blu-Ray player that will sell for $1800, owch.

     

    So who's winning the movie release race, HD DVD or Blu-Ray?

     

    In the early drive to release movies Blu-Ray had a reputation for taking an edge over HD DVD in sheer number of titles.  But I don’t see it, looks to me like the race is pretty even at the outset.  You can see a Blu-Ray releases list here and compare with this HD DVD release list.

  • TiVo Series3

    Not only is TiVo alive and well despite some bad news for the company last year, they're making their most significant leaps in PVR technology yet seen.  The TiVo Series 3 was unveiled at CES last week and TiVo's reps say it will be available by “mid to late ’06”.  This is the TiVo unit with everything TiVo users have been looking for.

     

    Finally a TiVo (non-DirecTV) that includes HDMI.  The Series3 will include a total of six tuners:  Two ATSC tuners (for HD over air broadcasting) and two NTSC tuners (for standard old fashioned TV) plus two cable tuners for a total of six tuners in TiVo’s new Series3 set top boxes boxes.  But you'll still only be able to record two programs at a time.  The inclusion of a CableCARD slot and full HDTV are two features that will put TiVo over the top of competing PVR’s furnished by your satellite or Cable TV Company.

     

    If you’re stuck fiddling around with your cable companies Motorola box for your HD-PVR fix you know what an annoying implementation of the technology it is.  TiVo brings you a fast easy to use PVR with tons of extra features and a user friendliness unknown to any VCR.  Now you won’t have to sacrifice anything if you’re using cable TV.  The ability to pull over air transmission in full HD is a great feature for anyone with an HD-Monitor that doesn’t include a built in tuner.  All the major US television networks now broadcast in HD over the air. 

     

    Rumor on the PVR blog has it that this will probably retail around $800 but so far there is no announced price. 

  • iPod Video's Real Story - iTunes

    iPod video opens a new era not only for the 5th generation iPod's evolution but more importantly in Apple’s retail arm iTunes.

     

    The iPod Video is certainly another great device by Apple a worthy descendant of the iPod pedigree.  Now we can add Vid-Casting to the bag of iPod tricks.  Keep up with your favorite TV shows on the 2.5” LCD screen by docking to your workstation and synching up with iTunes.  iTunes now sells episodes of many popular TV shows from a variety of networks for $1.99 an episode.

     

    The 2.5” screen is an eye squinter to be sure but it actually looks very good and even has an optional output cable you can buy from Apple that allows you to port the video to your TV set.  The results of using the iPod video as a source on your TV are second rate, pixilation is visible but then you don’t buy the iPod video to playback on your TV anyway.  It looks quite sharp on the tiny screen with no visible screen door effect that troubles many LCD monitors.  The “screen door” is the problem inherent in LCD visual technologies where you can see visible space between pixels.  The space is created by circuits that are required to bring voltage to the liquid crystals that act as a color switch for each pixel.  Some might say that on such a tiny screen it’s hard enough to see the pixels let alone space between them, in other words it should be easy to present a great looking image at only 2.5”.  But you have give Apple credit for presenting excellent clarity to match the sound quality of their well built digital media players.

     

    The iPod has long since set the benchmark with sound quality on portable digital audio players by using high end Wolfson DACs on all iPod models.  DAC stands for Digital Analog Converter and is the most important part in creating sound using digital sources such as DVD or CD players.  In fact any digital source is only as good as its DAC, Mpeg3 decoders like a Digital Audio Players (MP3 players), digital cable boxes and satellite receivers decode Mpeg2 using DACs.  By using the respected Wolfson chips Apple scores high points from audiophiles as Wolfson is found in many of the most expensive CD/DVD players by names like Arcam.  Playback of uncompressed audio using Apple’s lossless compression technology brings the iPod up to par with some of the finest digital sources for home audio.  Thanks to Apple raising the standards of all DAPs (Digital Audio Players) Wolfson DACs are found in other fine DAPs like the Rio Karma.

     

    Has iTunes unlocked Pandora’s Box?

     

    iTunes selling TV is another important step in letting digital technologies bring choices to the consumer.  This is the real breakthrough behind the iPod Video.  You may hate the idea of watching a TV show on a tiny screen with headphones personally, most people wouldn’t bother.  But everyone stands to benefit from the entertainment industry finding new and interesting ways to peddle their wares online rather than fighting digitization in courts.  It brings us closer to the day we may purchase only the shows we want from the local cable company.  The cable TV providers will adapt or we’ll just download, legally direct from the networks or some other Vid-casting service provider like iTunes.

     

    But what will this brave new digital world that promotes “power to the consumer” do to the advertisers we have successfully side-stepped?  They’ll adapt of course.  Advertisers will use more product placement and will more deeply penetrate the very fabric of what entertains us.  We’ve already seen episodes of TV shows written to promote a product or service.  The message of mass sponsorships has already become the entertainment itself on at least one entire Cable TV network.  MTV is an example of one continuous infomercial for a consumer lifestyle aimed at the most vulnerable segment of our population, the young.

  • Budget Bookshelf Speakers

    There’s a great article on Audioholics today, the budget bookshelf speaker shootout.  I love to see real world affordable gear get highlighted and compared.  As an average consumer I could easily see myself adding one of these speakers to my kit as rear surrounds or to a second room as primary speakers. 

    The competitors in the Battle of the Budget Bookshelf Face Off: 

    Axiom M3Ti

    $275 pr

    BIC DV-62

    $275 pr

    Klipsch RB-15

    $299 pr

    Unisound DAC 1.5s

    $160 pr

    The only ones I’d had any experience with are Axiom, a fine fine speaker manufacturer and Klipsch of course are something of an acquired taste, known for their bright sound with emphasis on mid-highs they’re well suited for rock music.  In fact most guitar oriented sounds will benefit from most Klipsch speakers by being incredibly detailed and dynamic.  Obviously these are my favs of the bunch.  I’ve heard of the BIC and read where there is a cult following for these speakers.  What many users do is take these bookshelf speakers and make a few simple modifications to them that apparently bring out huge sound.  But no such mods are included in the tested speakers so consequently they didn’t fare so well in the battle.

    In build quality they take these speakers apart and highlight each of them and judge them for how well constructed they are.  No surprise that Klipsch has the best build of all with Axiom very close behind.  The BIC’s must be screaming for these mods because they were last in build quality.   

    Using this receiver by Yamaha (a fine reference for the testing of any mid-fi speaker system) they compared the lot of the speakers with a variety of music and movie soundtracks.  The article makes a great read and definitely follow the link and check out the details if you’re interested in any of these speakers or just want to know who makes some nice budget bookshelfs today.  Of course the top speakers (surprise - surprise) follows closely to the tops in build quality.  Klipsch and Axiom get a tie for first.  Klipsch get the first place for rock and movie soundtracks for their aggressive in – yo – face sound quality.  The Axiom’s are more refined. 

  • Digital Holidays

    Happy Holidays everyone!  I hope you all had a Merry Christmas and have a Happy New Year! 

    This is the time of year when we think inward of character traits that make us better people, like sharing.  Here is a great example of how I'm willing to share with my wife.  She loves those geeky math games like Hexic for Xbox 360.  But I like to watch hockey especially when the Leafs are playing.  When I watch hockey on TV I just about always listen to music.  I don't really like announcers.  I was thrilled during the CBC strike they were actually playing hockey games with no anouncer at all.  Just the sounds of skate blades on ice, the crowds build up and reactions.  So, in liew of anouncer gag I am back to listening to music while I watch hockey.  The Xbox 360 affords me the opportunity to do a random shuffle of a playlist while I watch.  However one of the Xbox 360's iPod limitations is that it can only playback 100 song playlists.  This is a limitation that needs to be overcome!  Hopefully a forthcoming version of the iPod compatibility will allow for (less than) >100 song playlists.

    So, illustrated in this image are the fruits of my sharing nature.  Using my TV's basic split screen capability (as much as I complain about Sony they make a nice TV set) I let my wife play her game while I watch the hockey game and listen to music at the same time.  It's exploitation of the digital nirvana that is the modern home entertainment system.
  • Sony Vs Microsoft; Who is the evil empire?

     

    There is a natural tendency to hate big business in North America.  We have our corporate favourites but they can easily fall to overexposure and advertisers know this and are careful with the brands they try to sell us.  Both Microsoft and Sony are heavyweights in big business and the word Evil is admittedly loaded.  We hate success on a primal level, it's a trait embedded in our character mythology it makes us who we are to want to associate a philosophical trait like evil to something as indifferent as a corporation.  But here goes my indulgence.

     

    Microsoft is well hated in software circles.  Linux-heads hate Gates and are actually doing something about it, composing their own OS.  Mac users hate Windows because it copied them and became more successful.  The old-school reason for hating Microsoft was that it was Gates who introduced the concept of paying for software.  Many newbie kids still have this original hate of Gates and Microsoft but don't realize it, they just know the 1337 hate so it must be cool.

     

    Microsoft made no secret they’ve wanted to be a TV set top box for well over a decade.  Philips created CDi back in the 80s which introduced some clever standards but I think we can safely say it failed.  Philips tried again but collaborated with Sony this time on the more successful WebTV.  This didn’t go unnoticed by Microsoft who bought webTV.  Ironically neither party (Sony nor Microsoft) knew it at the time but they were destined to wage a fierce battle over the TV/Computer paradigm.  The same product WebTV was both Microsoft and Sony's first step into this hopelessly immature space. 

     

    Sony devastated the console market with the PlayStation, single-handedly sinking Sega who never make another console after its failed Dreamcast and sticking to Nintendo.

     

    As we all probably know Microsoft dusted off their sleeves and prepared for a costly war with the current video game champs.  Microsoft had a unique vision of a gaming machine that would also be a media device, introduce a community and then an online shopping method.  This trinity through the gaming shows rare vision and has hastened the advancement of possibilities in internet technologies.  We enjoy unprecedented access to new and unique experiences from these creations by Microsoft.

     

    At the end of the day, the Microsoft hating Sony-suck ups, Linux-brats and Apple-snobs can have your disposition against Microsoft.  I’ve always HATED SONY (well, hate's a strong word, lets say I've avoided most of their products) for the exact reasons most people hate Microsoft.  Sony really is an evil empire.

     

    Sony is a consumer electronics giant and with the exception of TVs the Sony name is either garbage or just a mediocre (but often reliable) example of what that technology can offer.  Sony speakers?  Forget about it!  Far better speakers from dedicated speaker companies exist for less money.  Sony hi-fi ES line, way too expensive for what you get.  Try brands like NAD, Rotel or Outlaw if you want better quality for less money.  Sony’s cheap hi-fi gear (IE $200 5.1 receivers) are garbage, but you knew that.  They don’t hold a candle to comparably priced Onkyo, Yamaha, Kenwood or just about any other.  To be fair to Sony their digital cameras/camcorders are generally great products if you’re not shooting professionally.  They often make unremarkable but reliable performers.  Of course Sony TVs rock the house!

     

    Why is Sony the evil empire?

     

    Close your eyes and think of a song… got it?  Okay, there is a base 50% chance that song is owned by Sony.  Yes, Sony about half the music the world listens to and a hell of a lot of movies.  This is what gives Sony the balls to put hi-fi, visual and optical storage advancements back years by releasing proprietary standards that compete with the accepted standards.  This leads to poor sales of either competing standard, expensive media and general delays of the technologies maturity.  Sony went to war with the rest of the video tape industry with their own standard called Beta that gave considerable competition to VHS.  Years later when high resolution audio started with DVD-Audio Sony created SACD to compete and throw the whole hi-res audio into a spin.  Now we see Sony releasing Blu-Ray just when HD DVD should have been the accepted standard (and if you like computers and plan on using Windows Vista HD DVD is the clearly superior standard).  A new format war is brewing between Sony and everybody else because Sony wants to control the next gen optical storage medium.

     

    Everybody uses a DRM nowadays.  They suck but they’re something we’ll just have to get used to if we value digital consumables.  DRMs like Apple’s FairPlay and Microsoft’s PlaysForSure are harmless and if you’re tricky you can crack it and remove it or just live with it and play by their annoying rules.  But Sony’s version of the DRM called RootKit (you must install this when you use a Sony/BGM CD) is a Trojan horse.  Yes, Sony knowingly released CDs with a harmful component secretly included.  Sony’s own brand of DRM demonstrates their contempt for their customers.  If Sony is the real evil Empire then Microsoft is the antidote.  Jason Garms, program manager of Anti-Malware Technology Team on Microsoft and has said they’ll include detection and removal of Sony’s Rootkit in Window’s Anti-Spyware beta.

     

    Today Sony seems content to give us a gaming only machine the multi-media powerhouse PS3 will be released next year.  Microsoft has stuck to the deep vision they've had since the early 90s, seeing the livingroom media come to fruition with Xbox Live.  XBL is not only a gaming community but it's becoming the first real remote control e-commerce marketplace.  There is nowhere else for it to go but start integrating more MSN features like music and eventually movies or TV shows, all to be played through Xbox 360 (or future iterations of the Microsoft STB).

  • Journey to Windows MC

    They say the thousand mile journey begins with the first step.  My first step to digitizing all my media will be documented here on this blog.  It's been done, sure.  This isn't promising to be the definitive guide to all things HTPC.  But thus far, a working HTPC has eluded me.  I've been interested and I've been touting the strengths of going with digital media and storing away all those DVDs and CDs for a long time.  Actually the CDs are pretty much unsed in my house anymore, as with most who have simply converted to MP3 and have other means of playing them back.

    But movies and TV programming, recording shows and storing them away permanently (or even burning them to DVD) is something else.  I've been using a PVR for awhile but it's only transient.  I'm not really building a collection of media with it.  It's a handy device, don't get me wrong.  But the PVR alone has a finite storage and isn't designed to be ported to mpg2 format to my PC.  I'm sure there are hacks that could perform this operation but I'm going to go the HTPC server route.  I have the Xbox360 now, so it'll be the machine I keep near the TV that hooks up using component video and optical audio S/PDIF connection to my main home system.

    Here is what I'm interested in being able to do with the 360 as my extender:

    Xbox 360 Media Setup

    With Xbox 360, you can:

    Windows Media Center

    Connect to a computer running Windows Media Center and

    • Listen to your music collection
    • View pictures
    • Watch live TV
    • Pause and replay live TV
    • Record TV shows then watch them later
    • Watch Videos
    • Download and watch movies
    • Buy music online

    Music

    Pictures

    Connect to a computer running Windows XP Service Pack 2 and

    • Listen to your music collection
    • View pictures  

    I dug this up from Xbox.com from their faq about what formats exactly are supported for streaming to the 360 from the WinMC HTPC machine.  This are the most important steps in the thousand mile journey, deciding there are indeed services that are valuable to getting this job done.

    I'll make a new category on this blog so I can keep track of the HTPC.  This will be the first entry.

    Q: What media file types are supported when streaming content from a PC running Windows XP Media Centre Edition 2005?

    A:

    Video

    Windows Media Video (WMV) 7, WMV 8, and WMV 9

    Maximum resolution of 1920x1080 (1080p)

    Windows Media Audio Standard or Windows Media Audio Pro audio

    WMV content may be Windows Media DRM-protected

    MPEG-1 with MPEG-1 layer I or II audio

    MPEG-2

    Maximum resolution of 1920x1080 (1080i)

    AC-3 or MPEG-1 layer I or II audio

    WMV Image 1 (Photo Story 1 & 2), and WMV Image 2 (Photo Story 3)

    Audio

    Windows Media Audio (WMA) 7 through WMA 9

    WMA Standard content may be Windows Media DRM-protected

    WMA Professional

    WMA Professional content may be Windows Media DRM-protected

    WMA Lossless

    Windows Media DRM protected WMA Lossless is not supported

    MP3

    Other formats that have a DirectShow decoder installed on the host computer that outputs pulse code modulation (PCM) audio.